Milad Safabakhsh

How an Oscar Wilde Portrait Shaped Photography Copyright in 1884

Tucked inside the Library of Congress collection is a modest color advertising card from the Burrow-Giles Lithographic Company, whose New York premises stood at 20 and 22 Gold Street. The face of the card presents Oscar Wilde reclining on a sofa, one hand holding a shut book and his head leaning against the other. The reverse, however, is pure commerce, listing prices for hats and bonnets. Roughly 85,000 copies were sold or put up for sale, and the photographer whose image had been reproduced took the company to court. That dispute eventually reached the Supreme Court, which had to answer a question that sounds simple but was new to American law: can a photograph have an author?

A Portrait Worth Litigating Over

The photographer was Napoleon Sarony, a well-known studio operator in New York whose celebrity sitters included the Irish writer during his American lecture tour of 1882. Sarony’s portrait was a carefully staged studio work, and the lithographers had used it without permission to decorate a promotional card for their hat and bonnet trade. For a printing firm, the image was simply a source of artwork. For Sarony, it was the product of decisions about pose, props, lighting, and expression, all of which he had controlled.

The Question Before the Court

Photography was still a young medium in 1884, and copyright law had been written with maps, books, and paintings in mind. The Copyright Act of 1870 had extended protection to photographs, but critics argued that a camera merely recorded what stood in front of it, leaving no room for a creator’s mind. If that view held, a photograph would belong to no one in particular, and anyone could copy it freely.

The justices disagreed. In their opinion, a photograph qualifies for protection when it is an original intellectual conception of its maker, expressed through choices the photographer makes about the subject and the image. Posing the sitter, arranging the drapery and furniture, adjusting the light, and capturing a particular mood all count as creative acts. The Court therefore upheld Sarony’s copyright, and the lithographers’ use of his image was found to infringe it.

Why the Ruling Still Matters to Photographers

The decision in Burrow-Giles Lithographic Co. v. Sarony established that authorship in photography rests on creative control rather than on the mechanics of the camera. That principle underpins how working photographers think about their rights today. A product shot lit with careful setups, a portrait built around a deliberate gesture, or a landscape framed with a specific composition can each reflect the kind of original judgment the Court recognized in 1884.

The ruling also reminds commercial users of imagery that a visual is rarely just a visual. Stock libraries, advertising agencies, and print shops all rely on licensing agreements precisely because a single photograph can carry a creator’s artistic investment. Wilde’s languid pose on a sofa may have been meant to suggest elegance, yet it also helped define a legal principle that still shapes the industry.

A Small Card With a Large Legacy

It is striking that the case grew out of an advertisement for hats and bonnets. The same printed piece that once promoted millinery now sits in a national archive as evidence of how a legal system first grappled with photographic authorship. For today’s photographers, the lesson is straightforward: the creative decisions behind an image are what give it value, and the law has recognized that value for more than 140 years.

Curated by
Featured Image: Photo by Brett Jordan on Unsplash
Cart0